In Colorado, the juvenile preliminary hearing right comes from C.R.S. 19-2.5-609. A teen charged in delinquency court with a class 1, 2 or 3 felony, or with certain class 4 to 6 felonies, can demand a hearing where prosecutors have to show probable cause. On Nov. 9, 2026, the Colorado Supreme Court held that a grand jury indictment of adult co-defendants doesn't cancel that right.
The case is People in the Interest of A.E.R., docket 26SA216, listed on the Colorado Judicial Branch opinions page as 2026 CO 68. It came up as an original proceeding, so the Supreme Court took it before the trial court had reached a final judgment. For any family whose child is charged in a case that also involves indicted adults, the ruling settles a question that could have cost the teen an important early check on the prosecution.
How the case started in Larimer County
In April 2026, Larimer County prosecutors got a grand jury indictment against five adults. Colorado Politics reported that prosecutors described them as part of a drugs-and-guns operation meant to benefit a street gang. The grand jury also found probable cause for offenses committed by a 17-year-old, identified in court papers as A.E.R. Prosecutors charged her separately, in a juvenile delinquency case.
According to Colorado Politics, both sides at first agreed that A.E.R. was entitled to a preliminary hearing. Then District Court Judge Joseph D. Findley asked for arguments, and prosecutors changed course. They argued that the grand jury had already found probable cause "by an independent body through a different, but just as reliable mechanism."
Findley agreed with them. He ruled that "the purpose of a preliminary hearing has been accomplished by the grand jury indictment." In July, Colorado Politics reported that the Supreme Court had agreed to step in.
A.E.R.'s defense argued that "the existence of a grand jury indictment cannot alter or diminish the procedural rights afforded to a juvenile." The defense also argued that a juvenile delinquency case can't be started by a grand jury indictment, so the indictment had no legal effect on her case.
What the Colorado Supreme Court decided
Justice Richard L. Gabriel wrote the opinion and rejected Findley's reasoning. He started with the statute. "The foregoing provisions are plain and unambiguous," he wrote, according to Colorado Politics. The law gives "a juvenile in a delinquency proceeding the statutory right to a preliminary hearing" when the charge qualifies and the hearing is properly requested.

"Here, A.E.R. satisfied all of these statutory requirements," Gabriel wrote.
The court also refused to treat the grand jury finding as a stand-in for her hearing. "Here, we have different parties to the grand jury proceeding and the proposed preliminary hearing," the opinion says. The key line: "A.E.R. was not indicted by the grand jury, nor, by law, could she have been."
That last point is what decided the case. Juvenile delinquency cases in Colorado run on their own track under Title 19, the Children's Code, and they start with a delinquency petition instead of an indictment. A grand jury's finding about a teen who could not legally be indicted doesn't take the place of the hearing the juvenile statute guarantees.
The contrast with adult cases matters here. According to a Colorado defense practitioner's blog, adults whose cases go forward on a grand jury indictment don't get a preliminary hearing. In effect, prosecutors asked the trial court to apply that adult rule to a juvenile. The Supreme Court said the juvenile statute doesn't allow it.
What a preliminary hearing tests
A preliminary hearing doesn't decide guilt. It asks whether there is probable cause to believe the teen committed the offense charged. The Colorado Criminal Lawyer Blog explains that "the prosecution need not present evidence sufficient to convict," and that the judge "views the evidence and draws inferences in the prosecution's favor." That's a low bar, but prosecutors still have to clear it.
Under C.R.S. 19-2.5-609, the hearing works like this:
-
The teen is not asked to enter a plea.
-
The prosecution has the burden of establishing probable cause.
-
The defense may cross-examine prosecution witnesses and present its own evidence.
-
The court may relax the rules of evidence.
-
A juvenile court judge or a magistrate may run the hearing.
Which juvenile charges qualify
Not every felony charge comes with an automatic right to the hearing. Under subsection (1) of the statute, a juvenile accused of a delinquent act that would be a class 1, 2 or 3 felony "may demand and receive a preliminary hearing." The same right applies to a class 4, 5 or 6 felony if the charge:
-
carries mandatory sentencing,
-
is a "crime of violence" under C.R.S. 18-1.3-406, or
-
is a sexual offense under part 4 of article 3 of title 18.
Either the district attorney or the juvenile can demand the hearing.
Other class 4 to 6 felonies go to a dispositional hearing instead, where the parties evaluate the case and may try to resolve it. A teen held in custody on one of those charges can still demand a preliminary hearing, but the court has to vacate it once the teen is released.
Colorado Politics did not list the specific charges A.E.R. faces. The Supreme Court's ruling depended on her meeting the statute's requirements, not on any particular offense.
The deadlines families can't miss
Request deadline: A party "shall file a written motion for a preliminary hearing not later than fourteen days after the advisement hearing" (C.R.S. 19-2.5-609(1)(a)). If the motion isn't filed in time, the hearing can be lost.

If your child is detained: "The preliminary hearing must be held within thirty-five days after the filing of the motion," unless the court finds good cause for a delay.
If your child is not detained: The hearing is set as promptly as the court's calendar allows.
Discovery: The prosecution must make discovery available at or after the advisement hearing.
What the hearing can do for a teen's defense
The biggest possible outcome is a dismissal. If the court finds that "probable cause does not exist, it shall dismiss the delinquency petition," and the teen is released from related restrictions and temporary orders. That isn't always the end of it, though. Prosecutors can move to refile with a verified affidavit.
If the court does find probable cause, it enters that finding and sets an adjudicatory trial. The hearing can still help. The Colorado Criminal Lawyer Blog notes that "courts say discovery is not the purpose of a preliminary hearing," but the hearing produces sworn testimony from prosecution witnesses. It can also knock out counts the evidence doesn't support and give the defense leverage in plea talks. In a group case like A.E.R.'s, where the evidence was first presented to a grand jury the teen's lawyer never saw, the chance to question witnesses under oath is especially valuable.
When a magistrate rather than a judge makes the probable cause finding, either side can ask for review under C.R.S. 19-1-108(5.5).
What parents should do now
-
Tell the juvenile defender about any related adult case right away. If adults in the same investigation were indicted, the defense needs to know early so prosecutors can't argue later that the indictment covers your child.
-
Ask whether the charge qualifies. Class 1 to 3 felonies qualify, and so do some class 4 to 6 felonies. Ask the lawyer which category your child's charge falls into.
-
Confirm the motion was filed within 14 days of the advisement hearing. Write down the advisement hearing date and count forward.
-
If your child is detained, track the 35-day clock from the date the motion was filed, and ask the lawyer about any delay the court approves.
-
If a magistrate rules, ask about review. The statute allows a party to seek review of a magistrate's preliminary hearing finding.
How far the ruling reaches
The decision is narrow. It interprets the juvenile statute and holds that a teen who meets its requirements gets the hearing. It doesn't change the rule for adults indicted by a grand jury, and it doesn't decide anything about the evidence against A.E.R. What it does is block prosecutors from using an adult indictment to skip a juvenile's statutory hearing when the teen was never part of that grand jury proceeding and couldn't have been.
For a family whose child is charged alongside adults, that means the teen keeps the same procedural protection as any other juvenile facing a qualifying charge, provided the request is filed on time.
Related reading
-
If the Bureau of Prisons Miscounts Your First Step Act Credits, Where Do You Turn?
-
How to Seal a Juvenile Record Before Your Teen Applies to College
-
How Families Can Challenge a Gang Label Before It Follows a Teen to Court
Sources
-
Colorado justices: Teen defendant entitled to probable cause review, Colorado Politics, Nov. 9, 2026
-
Colorado Supreme Court intervenes in 3 ongoing cases, Colorado Politics, July 9, 2026
-
Colorado Supreme Court Opinions, Colorado Judicial Branch
-
Opinion page for 26SA216, People in the Interest of A.E.R., Colorado Judicial Branch
-
C.R.S. 19-2.5-609, Preliminary hearing, dispositional hearing, colorado.public.law
-
Preliminary Hearings in Colorado: the Probable Cause Standard, Colorado Criminal Lawyer Blog, Oct. 20, 2026
Note: This article contains AI-assisted content and has been reviewed by our editorial team.
IMPORTANT NOTICE: GavelDaily.com is an advertising and information service, not a law firm. Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. The information you provide will be shared with licensed criminal defense attorneys in your area who may contact you about your inquiry. All submissions are treated as confidential by our service, but attorney-client privilege does not attach until you formally retain an attorney. Any attorney you connect with through this service is independently responsible for their legal advice and representation. Free consultations are subject to individual attorney availability. If you are facing an immediate legal emergency, contact your local public defender's office or call 911.
